Read More: Culinary History of Pork Picnic Shoulder
Defining the Cut: Picnic vs. Boston Butt
Before diving into the history, it’s important to clarify the distinction between the picnic shoulder and the Boston butt, as they are often confused. Both come from the pig’s shoulder, but they are distinct cuts.
- Boston Butt (or Pork Butt): This cut comes from the upper portion of the shoulder, above the blade bone. It’s well-marbled with fat, making it ideal for slow cooking methods like braising and smoking. Despite its name, it has nothing to do with the city of Boston, nor is it from the rear of the pig. The name’s origin is debated, but likely comes from the barrels (“butts”) in which these cuts were packed and shipped in pre-refrigeration days, possibly originating or passing through Boston.
- Picnic Shoulder (or Picnic Ham): This cut comes from the lower portion of the shoulder, closer to the foreleg. It’s generally leaner than the Boston butt, with more connective tissue and a tougher texture. It often includes the shank (lower leg) bone and may be sold with the skin on (which becomes crackling when roasted).
Ancient Roots: Resourcefulness and Whole-Hog Utilization
The history of the picnic shoulder, like that of many other less-tender cuts of meat, is rooted in the principle of whole-hog utilization. In pre-industrial societies, wasting any part of an animal was unthinkable. Every cut, from the prized loin to the humble feet, had its place in the culinary repertoire.
While specific historical records focusing solely on the picnic shoulder are scarce, it’s safe to assume that it was utilized alongside other cuts in ancient cultures where pork was a staple. The Romans, known for their sophisticated culinary practices, likely used the picnic shoulder in various dishes, perhaps in stews or as part of a mixed grill. In ancient China, where pork has been a culinary cornerstone for millennia, the picnic shoulder would have been incorporated into the diverse range of dishes that utilized every part of the pig.
Medieval Europe: Stews, Pottages, and the Art of Slow Cooking
In medieval Europe, the picnic shoulder, along with other less-tender cuts, found its niche in slow-cooked dishes. Stews, pottages, and other one-pot meals were staples of the medieval diet, particularly for the peasantry. These dishes allowed tougher cuts of meat to become tender and flavorful through long, slow simmering.
The picnic shoulder, with its bone and connective tissue, would have contributed richness and body to these dishes. The bone marrow added flavor and nutrients, while the collagen in the connective tissue broke down into gelatin, creating a silky, unctuous texture.
While medieval cookbooks don’t often specify the exact cut of pork used in these recipes, it’s highly likely that the picnic shoulder, being a readily available and affordable cut, was a common ingredient.
Regional Variations: A Global Tapestry of Picnic Shoulder Dishes
As culinary traditions evolved and diversified across the globe, the pork picnic shoulder found its way into a wide array of dishes, each reflecting local ingredients, flavors, and cooking techniques.
- Southern United States: Pulled Pork and Barbecue: The picnic shoulder plays a significant role in Southern barbecue traditions. While the Boston butt is often preferred for pulled pork due to its higher fat content, the picnic shoulder is also used, particularly in regions where whole-hog barbecue is practiced. The picnic shoulder, when slow-smoked, yields a flavorful and slightly leaner pulled pork. It is also sometimes cured and smoked, similar to ham, especially in home cooking.
- Puerto Rico: Pernil: Pernil, a slow-roasted pork shoulder, is a classic Puerto Rican dish, often served during holidays and special occasions. While some recipes call for the Boston butt, many traditional pernil recipes utilize the picnic shoulder, often with the skin on. The skin is scored and rubbed with a flavorful marinade, resulting in crispy crackling and succulent, tender meat.
- Cuba: Lechón Asado: Cuban lechón asado (roast pork) also frequently uses the picnic shoulder, particularly for smaller gatherings where a whole pig is not practical. The shoulder is marinated in a mojo sauce, typically containing sour orange juice, garlic, oregano, and cumin, and then slow-roasted until tender.
- Philippines: Pata: Pata, although usually refering to the hock or knuckle, can use the picnic shoulder. It often braised until tender then deep-fried. Crispy pata is a well known dish.
- Europe: In various European cuisines, the picnic shoulder is used in stews, braises, and other slow-cooked dishes. In Germany, it might be used in Schweinshaxe (roasted pork knuckle), although this dish more commonly uses the ham hock.
The 20th Century and Beyond: Affordability and Versatility
In the 20th century, the picnic shoulder remained a relatively affordable cut of pork, making it a popular choice for budget-conscious families. It was often sold as a “picnic ham,” sometimes pre-cooked and smoked, providing a less expensive alternative to traditional ham.
While the picnic shoulder may not have enjoyed the same culinary prestige as some other cuts, its versatility and affordability ensured its continued presence in home kitchens. It could be roasted, braised, stewed, smoked, or even ground for use in sausages or other dishes.
A Modern Renaissance: Rediscovering Flavor and Value
In recent years, there has been a renewed appreciation for less-expensive and often-overlooked cuts of meat, including the pork picnic shoulder. Several factors have contributed to this trend:
- The Nose-to-Tail Movement: This culinary philosophy, emphasizing the use of every part of the animal, has brought renewed attention to cuts like the picnic shoulder, highlighting their flavor and potential.
- Economic Considerations: As food prices rise, consumers are increasingly seeking out affordable and versatile cuts of meat.
- Culinary Experimentation: Chefs and home cooks are becoming more adventurous, exploring different cuts and cooking techniques.
The pork picnic shoulder, with its rich flavor and potential for tender, succulent results when cooked properly, is perfectly suited to this culinary landscape. It’s a cut that rewards slow cooking, allowing the flavors to develop and the tough connective tissue to break down.
From Humble Origins to Culinary Star
The culinary history of the pork picnic shoulder is a story of resourcefulness, adaptability, and the enduring appeal of flavorful, affordable food. From its humble origins as a staple in peasant cuisines to its modern-day resurgence as a versatile and valued cut, the picnic shoulder has proven its staying power. Its ability to transform into a variety of delicious dishes, from Southern pulled pork to Puerto Rican pernil, from hearty stews to crispy pata, ensures its continued presence on tables around the world. It is a testament to the fact that culinary greatness can be found even in the most unassuming cuts of meat.
Chef Tom Founder
Share
Click on the icons below to share "Title of the item to share"