Read More: History of Long Island Cheese Pumpkin
Early American Roots: A Pumpkin with Deep Ancestry
The Long Island Cheese Pumpkin is considered one of the oldest varieties of Cucurbita moschata cultivated in North America. While its precise origins are somewhat murky, it’s believed to have descended from squashes grown by Indigenous peoples of the Americas long before European colonization. These early pumpkins were likely smaller and more diverse in appearance than the standardized varieties we see today.
By the early 19th century, the Long Island Cheese Pumpkin, or a very similar ancestor, had become a well-established crop in the eastern United States, particularly on Long Island. This region, with its fertile soil and temperate climate, proved ideal for pumpkin cultivation. The Long Island Cheese Pumpkin, prized for its eating quality and long storage life, became a staple food for local families. There is evidence that it was being sold in New York City markets as early as the 1830s, and that it was listed in a seed catalog as early as 1888.
A Pie Pumpkin Par Excellence: The 19th and Early 20th Centuries
Throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries, the Long Island Cheese Pumpkin reigned supreme as the pie pumpkin of choice in the eastern United States. Its dense, smooth, stringless flesh and sweet, nutty flavor made it ideal for baking into pies, the quintessential American dessert. It was also valued for its versatility in other culinary applications, finding its way into soups, stews, and baked goods.
The pumpkin’s name, which alludes to its resemblance to a wheel of cheese rather than its flavor, reflects its widespread popularity during a time when home cheesemaking was a common practice. It was a familiar sight in gardens, farm stands, and kitchens across Long Island and beyond.
The Threat of Industrial Agriculture: A Near-Death Experience
The mid-20th century, however, brought challenges to the Long Island Cheese Pumpkin’s dominance. The rise of industrial agriculture, with its emphasis on uniformity, high yields, and transportability, favored newer, hybrid pumpkin varieties that were better suited to large-scale production and long-distance shipping. These newer pumpkins, while often visually appealing, often lacked the rich flavor and creamy texture of the Long Island Cheese.
As a result, the Long Island Cheese Pumpkin began to fade from the commercial market. It became increasingly difficult to find, relegated to the gardens of a dwindling number of farmers and seed savers who cherished its unique qualities. By the 1970s, this once-ubiquitous pumpkin was teetering on the brink of extinction, a victim of changing agricultural practices and evolving consumer preferences.
A Champion Emerges: Ken Ettlinger and the Revival
The Long Island Cheese Pumpkin might have vanished altogether were it not for the efforts of a dedicated group of seed savers and farmers, most notably a Long Island farmer named Ken Ettlinger. In the 1970s, Ettlinger, recognizing the culinary and historical significance of this heirloom variety, began actively collecting and growing Long Island Cheese Pumpkin seeds. He was selling his pumpkins at a roadside stand, and was one of the few people still growing them at the time.
He championed the pumpkin’s exceptional flavor and texture, sharing it with chefs, gardeners, and anyone who would listen. His passion and advocacy played a crucial role in reintroducing the Long Island Cheese Pumpkin to a wider audience. He is largely credited with the revival of this variety.
The Heirloom Renaissance: A Triumphant Return
Ettlinger’s work coincided with a growing movement in the late 20th and early 21st centuries – the resurgence of interest in heirloom vegetables and fruits. Consumers, increasingly aware of the limitations of industrial agriculture and the importance of biodiversity, began seeking out unique, flavorful varieties that had been pushed aside by mainstream agriculture.
The Long Island Cheese Pumpkin, with its rich history and exceptional culinary qualities, was perfectly positioned to ride this wave of renewed appreciation. Chefs rediscovered its creamy texture and sweet flavor, incorporating it into their menus. Home gardeners embraced its unique appearance and delicious taste. Seed companies began offering Long Island Cheese Pumpkin seeds, making it more widely available to growers.
A Symbol of Resilience: The Long Island Cheese Pumpkin Today
Today, the Long Island Cheese Pumpkin has made a remarkable comeback. It’s a testament to the dedication of individuals like Ken Ettlinger, the resilience of heirloom varieties, and the growing awareness of the importance of preserving our food heritage. While it may not be as ubiquitous as it once was, the Long Island Cheese Pumpkin is once again a cherished variety, gracing farmers’ markets, restaurant menus, and Thanksgiving tables across the country.
Its story serves as a powerful reminder that the choices we make about the food we grow and eat have far-reaching consequences. By embracing heirloom varieties like the Long Island Cheese Pumpkin, we not only savor unique and delicious flavors but also contribute to the preservation of biodiversity and the rich tapestry of our culinary heritage. The Long Island Cheese Pumpkin, once on the brink of extinction, now stands as a symbol of hope and a delicious reminder of the treasures that can be found when we look beyond the ordinary.
Chef Tom Founder
Share
Click on the icons below to share "Title of the item to share"